Graph Search – Facebook’s Double-Edged Sword?

It was probably a long time coming and slightly predictable, but Facebook finally rolled out, in my opinion, its ‘weapon’ against the mighty search engine of Google: Graph Search. What are its implications to you as a user or to you as a brand or organization? 

Graph Search – Opening up a New World for Facebook?

The way I see it – and after a quick test on beta – this is potentially Facebook’s biggest (double-edged) sword so far.

How does Graph Search Work?

Simply put, when searching for phrases on the search bar, Facebook pulls up unique and highly personalized results for you based not just on your historical information but also on what it thinks are results you may like based on your social activities. Facebook basically shows you a search result based as near as it can on “social proof” and social connections.

Example: You know you probably have friends in the same city – Graph Search pulls out this information for you (as it did in the beta test for me).

A Can of Worms

graph searchIntegrating search into a social networking platform immediately puzzled me. “There’s Google for that!” I (perhaps) too quickly said. This argument holds water – Google is a giant, especially in the battlefield it has dominated for years, search. I know for a fact that I’m not on Facebook to search for things. I log on to update my friends, chat with them, or visit pages I like or manage. While social recommendation on search is a good example of “proof”, this eliminates the thus-far successful model of Google search – socially unbiased results.

There’s the privacy issue as well. Graph Search unearths results from people who have shared content with you – whether you’re still friends with them or not. Much remains to be seen, but it may be high time to be more stringent with our privacy settings.

A Game Changer

Search on a social networking site may prove to be a powerful referral tool. From how it works, it seems to be best for businesses or organizations with actual physical locations – think restaurants, auto-repair shops, and Laundromats. It never hurts to have search results previously validated by friends’ testimonials to come up in your own unique results page.

Should this take off and acquire the critical user mass needed for a feature to be retained, Graph Search has the potential to make Facebook a “one-stop-shop” platform. One no longer needs to go out of Facebook when looking for information, provided one doesn’t need impartial search results.

An Uncertain Future

Personally, this looks like another money-making ploy from Facebook to my eyes (yes, sponsored stories can be made to appear higher in search results) and is probably useless or even fatal for business pages which do not work on social testimonials. Still, I will not discount the fact that it’s a new feature that Google or even Bing should watch carefully – a billion users isn’t a small number by any count.

I believe it’s not going to be able to challenge Google in search any time soon.

In addition, I believe that this further emphasizes social engagement and increasing one’s networks, meaning numbers. It’s only logical that since your Graph Search results are determined by your social connections, it will pay to both have more connections and more quality (maybe same interest?) connections.

At the end of the day, will you prefer social-based results from Graph Search or impartial search results from the likes of Google?

Do let me know what you think of Facebook’s Graph Search! Like and Share this article if you enjoyed it!

Featured image from Tech Crunch, retrieved on January 16, 2012.

Facebook’s Graph Search

About Jason Cruz

Social Media Guy at MRM Worldwide Manila, McCann Worldgroup Philippines' digital arm. I live social media, positive thinking, & running. Marathoner, loves wine & hip hop. Social Media Examiner's Top 24 Social Media Blogs of 2013. Get in touch with me on Twitter, @jsncruz.

12 comments
Sort: Newest | Oldest
dustgaudan
dustgaudan like.author.displayName 1 Like

Ohh. This is an interesting tool. I may wanna try it. But I guess Google still prevails. :)

By the way, you work in McCann WG? Awesome! I wanna be in an advertising agency, too. But I don't know where to start.

jsncruz
jsncruz moderator

 @dustgaudan Hi Dust, yes, I am currently a Community Manager at MRM, the digital arm of MWG. Speak with me on Facebook; let's see where your core strengths lie and you never know, you may be suited in this industry.

 

Search is still all-Google for me.

JanJan
JanJan like.author.displayName 1 Like

I still prefer to use google search and always will be. I doubt this new graph search of facebook will be that huge for many people. Facebook should better stay to be just a simple social networking sites..and not add any new features that will just make this site complicated to use.

jsncruz
jsncruz moderator

 @JanJan I agree, Jan. We humans are creatures of habit and as long as we have the habit of searching for information on a search engine, a social networking site will have a difficult time trying to compete in the same space.

 

Thanks for dropping by and sharing that insight.

exlink2001
exlink2001 like.author.displayName 1 Like

I guess you have to continuously churn the machine that lays the golden egg. I just hope that Facebook do not forget the roots where it grew - social networking. If you ask me I also do not know if this development is good or not. I guess we will know sooner.

jsncruz
jsncruz moderator

 @exlink2001 Hi sir, yup, we will see the results of this within the year, I predict.

franckxethee
franckxethee like.author.displayName 1 Like

Currently even sponsored post now have priority in our wall feeds so the bias factor would really be dominant in Facebook searches in the future.  Facebook is too pressured because they are a listed Company that they would want to generate more profits to please their shareholders but I hope they don't forget their original recipe that made them successful, which is being a social media platform connecting people and business.  Leave the searches to Google for now.

jsncruz
jsncruz moderator

 @franckxethee Hi Franc, you bring up a very valid point on the issue of profitability.

 

I think they may be trying to do too many things to monetize their platform and it reduces the formerly-good user experience. I say formerly because I truly miss the days when ads were minimal and my news feed stories are those that my friends truly posted.

rochkirstin santos
rochkirstin santos like.author.displayName 1 Like

I am now using the beta version of the Facebook Graph Search and posted an article about it (short insight/review) on my blog as well. I've read posts saying that Facebook would not be going against Google in competing in the search engine arena but from the looks of it, this social media giant is gearing toward a likely similar path.

jsncruz
jsncruz moderator

 @rochkirstin santos Hi Rochkirstin, thanks for dropping by! I always enjoy your well-formed insights :)Hmm, who is Facebook kidding? Why enter the search business at all if to not compete against Google's immense market share, right? Social search is what Facebook is after - but thinking that way is ignoring the fact that two powerful Google products DO provide social share already: Google Search results determined by our Google+ connections :)

RyanKBiddulph
RyanKBiddulph like.author.displayName 1 Like

Neat change Jason.

 

I too feel FB although a monstrous network cannot challenge the Big G anytime soon in the search game. Funny you write this as I noted a shift in some of my FB search terms recently.

 

Thanks!

jsncruz
jsncruz moderator

 @RyanKBiddulph Hi Ryan! :)

 

Search is, and will continue to be, Google's playground. Unless Facebook introduces something a lot more useful and convenient, I doubt this will take off. Again, it's still too early to give a conclusive review of Graph Search. Thanks for dropping by!